← OrreryAll Orbits storiesAn Orrery publication

Points of Discovery

Five Years in Plain Sight

You will have heard that C. V. Raman looked at the blue Mediterranean from a ship in 1921, had his idea, and found the effect that bears his name with a few hundred rupees of apparatus. The sea was real, but it led somewhere else. His own students had seen the effect in 1923 and filed it under the wrong name. A younger man's diary shows how it was caught, two physicists in Moscow photographed it the same month, and the famous steamer ticket turns out to have a rather good explanation.

The myth

Now, you will have heard this one, and if you were at school in India you will have heard it every 28th of February, which is kept as National Science Day. A professor from Calcutta is sailing home from England in 1921. He stands on the deck, looks at the blue Mediterranean and wonders why it is blue. He has his idea. Seven years later, with a few hundred rupees' worth of apparatus, he finds that light changes colour when it bounces off molecules. He is so sure of the Nobel Prize that he buys his steamer ticket to Stockholm before anybody has told him he has won. And in 1930 he does win it, alone.

Here is the trouble for anyone hoping to knock it down. A good deal of it is true. There was a ship. There was a blue sea. There was a ticket, or so one witness says.

So let us treat it kindly and treat it as a case. Our question is a plain one. On the afternoon of 28 February 1928, who was in the room, what did they see, and was it really the first time anyone had seen it?

The cast

C. V. Raman, professor at Calcutta, who did his research at the Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science. Krishnan calls him simply Professor, and remembered him as "a 24-hour scientist" who talked out loud while he made his observations.

K. R. Ramanathan, who saw something odd in 1923 and tried very hard to wash it away.

S. Venkateswaran, who had a sample of very pure glycerine.

K. S. Krishnan, twenty-nine, a gifted theorist with a troublesome left eye. He kept a diary, he said, "Off and on". He is our best witness.

And Grigory Landsberg and Leonid Mandelstam, in Moscow, who were looking for something else in a crystal of quartz.

What the sea was good for

Let us begin with the ship, because that part can be checked against the man himself.

In his Nobel lecture of 11 December 1930, Raman says that a voyage to Europe in the summer of 1921 gave him his first sight of "the wonderful blue opalescence of the Mediterranean Sea". Notice the direction. He was on his way out. On the way home in September, aboard the SS Narkunda, he tested the water with a prism that cut out the reflected sky, and before he left the ship at Bombay he wrote a short note for Nature. The Public Domain Review, which presents it, quotes his conclusion that the blue of the deep sea is "a distinct phenomenon in itself". The usual view was that the sea only gave back the blue of the sky. Raman said no: the water's own molecules scatter the sunlight, as the air does.

He was right. But look at what kind of idea it is. In that sort of scattering the light comes off the molecule the same colour it went in. Blue simply scatters more than red. The effect that carries his name is the opposite kind of thing. A tiny part of the light comes off a different colour, because it has handed a little energy to the molecule or taken a little away.

So the voyage did not give him the effect. It gave him a question, and the question gave his laboratory seven years of work on scattered light. He says so himself: it became "the main theme of our activities at Calcutta".

The glow that would not wash out

Here is the awkward part.

In April 1923, Raman's lecture tells us, Ramanathan noticed that carefully cleaned liquids gave off, besides the ordinary scattered light, a second and far fainter light of a different colour. The usual suspect in such a case is fluorescence. That is the glow you get when a substance soaks up light and shines in a colour of its own, and a speck of impurity will do it. So Ramanathan purified his liquids and distilled them slowly, again and again. The faint light stayed just as it was.

Krishnan saw the same thing in many other liquids in 1924. In the summer of 1925 Venkateswaran tried to photograph its spectrum and, in Raman's words, "was unable to report any decisive results". Krishnan remembered it going by the name of the "weak fluorescence". Raman's lecture calls it "the phenomenon which had puzzled us ever since 1923".

Do you see what that means? The effect was there, in his own laboratory, with a label on it, for nearly five years. The label was wrong.

Two things moved the case along. One was Arthur Compton's work with X-rays, which, Raman said, "had made familiar the idea" that rays could lose a little energy in being scattered. The other was the glycerine. Venkateswaran reported that sunlight scattered in it came out "a brilliant green instead of the usual blue". At last the faint glow was strong enough to study.

Three weeks in February

Now we call Krishnan, and with care, because he speaks in two voices. One is his diary, extracts of which were printed in Current Science in December 1998. The other is a long talk he had in the 1950s with a younger physicist, S. Ramaseshan, who wrote it down four decades later and warns us that it is "a recollection" and not "an exact record". I shall say each time which voice it is.

The diary first. On Tuesday 7 February he finds that every pure liquid he tries shows the glow, and that the glow is strongly polarised. That matters. Polarised light vibrates in one direction, as scattered light does; the fluorescence of a vapour he had just tested showed no such thing. Raman would not believe it until he had looked through the filters himself. Then, the diary says, he remarked, "you do not mean to suggest, Krishnan, that all that is fluorescence". And a little further on: "He wondered how we missed discovering all that five years ago."

At about nine that night, the diary goes on, Raman suddenly came to the house where Krishnan and Venkateswaran were sitting after their meal, and called for him. They went down. He told them that what they had seen must be "the Kramers–Heisenberg Effect we had been looking for all these days". That was a prediction, made on paper in Europe in 1925, that scattered light might change its colour. They agreed to stop saying fluorescence and call it "modified scattering".

Here is a small puzzle. In Stockholm Raman said his guide had been the likeness to Compton's effect. The diary entry names Kramers and Heisenberg. A senior scientist who read Ramaseshan's article thought Krishnan, who knew the new quantum theory well, was being "rather generous" and had done more of the interpreting than he claimed. The trail goes cold there.

On the 9th Raman came back from a college lecture, heard that the effect showed in a vapour too, and called it "a first rate discovery". He had been "feeling miserable during the lecture", he said, at having to leave the experiment. On the 16th they sent a note to Nature. On the 17th Krishnan wrote, "I am having some trouble with my left eye." On Monday the 27th there was a religious ceremony at home and he stayed away.

And so to Tuesday the 28th. He came in only in the afternoon. They narrowed the light with filters and looked at it through a spectroscope, and found "to our great surprise" that the modified light was parted from the ordinary light "by a dark region". A gap. The new light had a colour of its own.

There the printed extract ends. A 2012 review of Krishnan's biography by S. C. Roy says the family's sixteen pages break off in an unfinished sentence, the rest being lost. For what came next we have only the later talk. In it Krishnan remembers "the great shout or really squeal" that Professor gave, and says Raman saw the effect by eye first while he himself had "the privilege of recording it for the first time on a photographic plate".

As for the few hundred rupees, I could not trace the figure. Raman's lecture lists a seven-inch telescope, colour filters, a mercury lamp and the smallest spectrograph the firm of Hilger made. Modest kit, but not nothing.

Meanwhile, in Moscow

Landsberg and Mandelstam were lighting quartz with a mercury lamp, hunting for a much finer effect. On 21 February 1928, according to the Russian physicist I. L. Fabelinskii, they found new lines on their photographs. They sent nothing to a journal until 6 May, and their paper came out on 13 July. Why so slow? Fabelinskii's reason has nothing to do with physics. A relative of Mandelstam's had been arrested and sentenced to death, and Mandelstam dropped his work to get the sentence reduced to exile. He succeeded. The paper waited.

Raman did not wait. Fabelinskii reports that the news was in a Calcutta paper the very next day, 29 February.

So who was first? It depends on what you count. The 21st is a week before the 28th, and Fabelinskii says plainly that Moscow saw it "one week earlier than Raman". But Calcutta had named the modified scattering on the 7th and written to Nature on the 16th, though without a spectrum. And here is the nicest clue. Rajinder Singh and Falk Riess, who read the Nobel papers, found that Orest Khvolson, a Leningrad professor and the Russians' own champion, gave the dates as 16 February for Raman and 21 February for Moscow, and asked that the prize be shared because they had found it "at the same time and independently".

Raman was not gracious. He wrote in Nature that the Russian paper had appeared "after sixteen other printed papers on the effect". The Nobel committee's expert ruled that the Russians "did not come to an independent interpretation", since their paper mentioned his work. Ten people had put Raman's name forward; only two named the Russians. Fabelinskii calls the result "obviously a mistake". In Russia they went on calling the thing combination scattering.

The steamer ticket

And the ticket? The oldest telling I could find is credited to Suri Bhagavantam, another of the students: "two months before he knew", Raman had "the supreme audacity of booking his steamer passage". Later writers say July. I have not found a receipt.

But two months before the November announcement is September, and Singh and Riess found that the committee's report naming Raman is dated 20 September. Did somebody tell him? Nobody knows. He had not left it all to fate: in December 1929 he had written to Niels Bohr asking for support, so that the prize "may go to India for the first time". And a man in Calcutta who waited for the official word, they point out, could not have reached Stockholm in time. Less second sight, then, than a campaign and a shipping timetable.

Why the truth is the better story

So here is the reveal. Nobody hid the Raman effect. It was seen in 1923 by Ramanathan, in 1924 by Krishnan, and chased in 1925 by Venkateswaran, and all that time it was filed under the wrong name. The moment of discovery was, in large part, the moment a stubborn man decided the name was wrong. Was it really Krishnan's discovery, as some said? Ramaseshan remembers his answer: "It is a blatant misrepresentation. The best I can say is that I participated actively in the discovery." All the experiments were planned by Professor, he said, and of his own part, "I executed them rather well."

The lone genius, then, had a relay team. One man saw the glow, one tested its polarisation until his eye gave trouble, one failed to photograph it and then brought the glycerine, and one gave the squeal. And in Moscow two more men got there by another road in the same month.

What of the credit? No one nominated Krishnan. Raman's lecture names him as having "very materially assisted". Later, recommending him for a professorship, Raman wrote, in the letter as Krishnan read it out to Ramaseshan, that had the prize been for the work of 1928 alone, "Krishnan could justly have come in for the share of the prize." Raman also put him up for the Royal Society. And then, for reasons I have not seen pinned down, he turned on him. Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, Raman's nephew, told Ramaseshan that Raman "made many statements impugning Krishnan's integrity". Krishnan called the change, by Ramaseshan's account, "the greatest tragedy of my life", and still would not say a word against his teacher.

The myth gives you a man, a sea and a flash. The truth gives you a busy laboratory, a wrong word, a diary that breaks off, and one remark set down in it. He wondered how they had missed it for five years. That, I think, is the real point of discovery. They had been seeing it for years. The hard part was believing it.


On sources. Raman's own words are from his Nobel lecture, "The molecular scattering of light" (11 December 1930), read in the Nobel Foundation's PDF: the outward voyage and "blue opalescence", the start of experiments on his return in September 1921, "the main theme of our activities", Ramanathan's observation of April 1923 and his purification, Krishnan in 1924, Venkateswaran in 1925 ("unable to report any decisive results"), "the phenomenon which had puzzled us ever since 1923", the Compton sentence, the glycerine ("a brilliant green"), the apparatus, and "very materially assisted". The lecture does not date the glycerine observation; Krishnan's later account puts it at the end of January 1928. The Narkunda, the prism, the note written before landing at Bombay and "a distinct phenomenon in itself" are from the Public Domain Review's page on Raman's note "The Colour of the Sea" (Nature 108, 367, 1921); I did not read the note itself, which is behind Nature's login, and "the usual view" is my summary of that page's account of Lord Rayleigh's opinion. All diary quotations are from "Extracts from Prof. K. S. Krishnan's Diary", a box printed inside S. Ramaseshan, "A conversation with K. S. Krishnan on the story of the discovery of the Raman effect", Current Science 75 (11), 10 December 1998, pp. 1265–1272, read in the journal's own scan: the entries for 7, 9, 16, 17, 27 and 28 February 1928 (the vapour without polarisation is from the entry for the 5th). I have not seen the manuscript or D. C. V. Mallik's study of it (Notes and Records of the Royal Society 54, 2000), which is paywalled. Everything marked as Krishnan's later talk is from the same article and is Ramaseshan's memory of a conversation in the 1950s (the article gives both 1953 and "four or five years before he died", which was in 1961), written up in 1998: "a 24-hour scientist", "Off and on", the squeal, the photographic plate, "blatant misrepresentation", "I executed them rather well", the letter to the Vice-Chancellor of Andhra University, "the greatest tragedy of my life" (printed in capitals), the Chandrasekhar remark, the anonymous "rather generous" comment and the reproduced Royal Society certificate. None of those words can be checked against a recording. Krishnan's age is from his birth year, 1898, given in S. C. Roy's review of Mallik and Chatterjee, Kariamanikkam Srinivasa Krishnan: His Life and Work, in Science and Culture 78 (7–8), 2012, which also supplies the sixteen pages and the unfinished sentence; the extract as printed in Current Science ends on a complete sentence, so the two do not quite agree. The Moscow dates, the Gurevich arrest (which Fabelinskii takes from E. L. Feinberg), the newspaper of 29 February, "one week earlier than Raman", "obviously a mistake" and the ticket sentence are from I. L. Fabelinskii, "The discovery of combination scattering of light in Russia and India", Physics–Uspekhi 46 (10), 2003, read in the journal's open PDF; he was a pupil of the Moscow school and writes as its advocate. Khvolson's dates and "at the same time and independently", Raman's "sixteen other printed papers" (Nature 123, 50, 1929), the expert's "did not come to an independent interpretation", the ten nominators, the committee report of 20 September 1930, the letter to Bohr of 6 December 1929 and the point about travelling time are from Rajinder Singh and Falk Riess, "Sir C. V. Raman and the story of the Nobel prize", Current Science 75 (9), 10 November 1998, pp. 965–971, who translate the committee papers from Swedish; their fuller 2001 paper in Notes and Records was not read. They quote the ticket sentence from G. Venkataraman, Journey into Light (p. 216); Fabelinskii prints it as Bhagavantam's. I have seen neither book nor Bhagavantam's original, so the ticket rests here on one recollection at two removes. The July date is given without a source by Preetish Kakoty in Physics World (2 October 2026) and by Wikipedia, citing Venkataraman's Raman and His Effect. The "few hundred rupees" echoes a remark attributed to Raman on Wikipedia; I could not trace it. National Science Day and its date are from G. V. Pavan Kumar's essay "C. V. Raman as a Science Communicator" (arXiv, 2024). Wikipedia's article on Raman dates Krishnan's key observation to 7 January 1928; the diary says 7 February, and I have followed the diary. The 1925 date of the Kramers–Heisenberg paper is the standard one, and Singh and Riess report the committee's view that Smekal (1923) and Kramers and Heisenberg (1925) had already supplied the theory. The American Chemical Society's landmark booklet and the Royal Society memoir of Raman could not be opened. Not confirmed: when the ticket was booked and what Raman knew; which theory he had in mind on 7 February; what the lost diary pages said; why he turned against Krishnan; and what the apparatus cost.

Original narrative history. Sources named in-line.  ·  Orbits is published by Orrery.