Cover Story · The Reality Gap desk
Gain Is Only Half the Product
Laser fusion's record shot returned 4.13 times the light that reached its target. The laser behind it turns about 0.7% of its electricity into that light. A power plant needs the product of the two, and every driver efficiency above 0.7% in the public record is a design value, not a measurement.
The Ecliptic · Issue No. 014 · October 15, 2026
The governing relation
Driver efficiency and target gain are one product, and NIF's is about 80 times short of breakeven.
The National Academies define engineering gain as driver efficiency × target gain × blanket multiplication × thermal efficiency. With the Academies' 1.1 and 0.4 for the last two, the gain a target must deliver falls in direct proportion as the driver gets more efficient.
- Wall-plug breakeven needs driver efficiency × gain of about 2.3; a plant recirculating 10% of its output needs about 23.
- NIF's record shot scores about 0.029 (0.007 × 4.13), roughly 80 times short of breakeven and 800 short of a plant.
- The Academies' own examples: a gain of 150 at a 15% driver and 320 at 7%.
- Repetition rate is a separate constraint: NIF fires about once a day; plant concepts fire 1–16 times a second.
The driver register
Every efficiency above NIF's 0.7% is a design, a target or a projection.
The register lists every inertial programme with a published driver efficiency. One row is measured at full scale. The rest describe machines that have not yet been built at plant energy or run at plant repetition rate.
- Diode-pumped lasers (LIFE, Longview, Inertia) design for 10–18% and fast firing; every efficient joule needs pump diodes, so capital scales with average power.
- Excimer lasers (Xcimer) accept 5–7% and plan to buy gain with very large, cheap pulses of 4–12 MJ; NRL's Electra ran 90,000 shots above 700 J and projects more than 7%.
- Pulsed power (Pacific Fusion) delivers about 10% of stored energy to the target in its design; a one-third-scale module reached about 440 GW in June 2026.
- Scale-up still ahead: Mercury's 55 J to LIFE's 2.2 MJ is about 40,000×; Xcimer's Phoenix (>1 kJ) to Vulcan (4–12 MJ) about 4,000–12,000×.
Three denominators
Net facility gain is a real milestone. It is not wall-plug breakeven.
Pacific Fusion measures its 2030 goal against energy stored in its capacitors. That leaves out the heat-to-electricity step, the largest single loss in any thermal plant, so a design can clear the milestone while still consuming more electricity than it returns.
- Beryllium-liner design: simulated facility gain 1.36 → engineering gain about 0.54–0.60, a net consumer.
- Aluminium-liner design: 4.75 → about 1.9–2.1.
- The company's commercial target, about five times the demonstration energy: about 24 → about 9.4–10.5, near a 10%-recirculation plant.
- Engineering breakeven needs facility gain of about 2.3–2.5; conversions assume 0.44 for thermal efficiency × blanket and 0.9–1.0 for capacitor charging (The Reality Gap estimates).